By Claire Cooper and Namgay Zam
The coverage of race by American Media has come under some amount of scrutiny ever since Ferguson in 2014. Race issues in the media have prompted national dialogue on several occasions. We highlight some incidences that have added to, as well as inspired the debate. We are hoping to engage with you on this issue, and invite you take our poll at the end of the article.
There have been many stories of racial discrimination since Ferguson. It is worthwhile to compare certain stories by American media with foreign coverage on the same because there are noticeable differences. For instance, when Donald Trump had a Univision journalist, Jorge Ramos, removed from his press conference, CNN did not highlight Ramos was Hispanic. They instead focused on him as a journalist. There was an outcry from the Latino population. But they weren’t indignant about his eviction as a journalist; they were indignant that a Latino journalist was mistreated by Trump who wants all illegal immigrants gone from the US in two years’ time. This was CNN’s headline: “Univision anchor ejected from Trump news conference.” The fact that Ramos is Hispanic appears only towards the end, and only once in the article:
The Guardian carried the Trump-Ramos incident on the same day, but focused on Ramos being Latino. The headline was: “Donald Trump ejects Latino news anchor as Iowa campaign gains ground.”
While CNN focused on the “squabble” between Trump and Ramos, The Guardian highlighted that, “Immigration and gender continued to hound the real estate mogul’s theatric run for the White House.”
A lack of race- consciousness leads to misinformation and worse, the propagation of stereotypes-criminal in the case of people of color, and often the endorsement of white privilege. Here is an example of one such case highlighted by CNN.
There are times when the race angle isn’t the most important in a story like in the case of the tragic deaths of the two journalists in Virginia. The Virginia case is also unique because the shooter himself said that he was at least partially motivated by race (as documented on his Twitter feed), but the media did not focus on that as the main motivation in the shootings.
In American media, one thing that is sure to add fuel to the fire is the Black Lives Matter movement, which has seen police officers at odds with large sections of the African American population over recent shootings, and is continuing the ever-present topic of race being portrayed as a motivator for violence in the media.
Race coverage by American media is evolving but it still has a long way to go. An article from The New Republic argues for a “race beat” in media houses:
The road to “there” is expected to be bumpy. At least we are on the road.
Have something to say? Let’s poll!
Claire Cooper and Namgay Zam.
2 Comments on “Race-consciousness for the Complete Story”
I believe that this is a nuanced example of racism in the media. We are taught to be unbiased in our reporting, and to not lead with any stereotypes. I think it was with this intention that Jorge Ramos was not initially identified as a latino media member. However, in this case, ethnicity is an integral part of the story. It was the culture that Ramos represents and fights for that was dismissed from Trump’s conference. These days, race is at the forefront of social discussion. Therefore, it should be at the forefront of journalism. Journalism, to be relevant, needs to address the issues of society.
Before I comment on the content of this blog, I’d like to touch on the presentation. I really like that you used a lot of images. Instead of linking out to content, you brought it in via screenshots, which you integrated into your blog. I also liked that you incorporated a poll, which I think is important. I think reaching out to readers in an attempt to understand their perspectives on issues as contentious as race and portrayals of race in the media.
I see your point about the media highlighting different aspects of a story to further a certain narrative. Some outlets want to focus on the “journalistic” aspects of stories like Ramos being thrown out, a sort of circling the wagons in defense of colleagues. That focus comes at the expense of more racial aspects.
I’d also like to see if this same difference in focus exists in global media outlets.
Comments are closed.